Looking ahead to Monday…

Dear sons of earthborn Erechtheus,

You will want to begin next week’s first meeting by returning to the discussion that was so ominously interrupted today.  Is the Boule of certified competents an idea whose time has come?  How does this proposal
fit into the history of Athenian public life?  How does it fit into the history of the intellectual revolution?  Does the history of Athens’ handling of the Peloponnesian War make it a more plausible suggestion or less?  How does your character respond to this cluster of issues? Please be sure to support your discussion with examples from Athenian history and the literature that you read this semester. Check the syllabus for the specific proposals and perhaps a short focus reading.

Once you have moved past this question the next issue to confront will be the issue of social welfare. The aftermath of war has caused severe economic instability. Will the Boule, however constituted, be paid?  How much and with whose money?  Will the Ekklesia be paid?  If so are you trying to redistribute wealth or merely open governmental participation up to all Athenians or both?  Are these wise and worthy goals? Are there other social programs that you would like to see enacted? or prevented? Finances will obviously place a crucial role in such decisions. Look back later this week for a blog post outlining Athens’ current and potential financial resources.

We want to tell you how proud we both are of your performance today.  You seem to be striking just the right balance now of boisterous rancor and respectful attention.  Keep up the good work.  If you have any questions, need advice or anything else, please don’t hesitate to contact us. We are and remain

Your biggest fans,

hoi theoi (the gods)

Cambyses’ lost army, found?


Hundreds of bleached bones and skulls found in the desolate wilderness of the Sahara desert may be the remains of the long lost Cambyses' army, according to Italian researchers. Alfredo and Angelo Castiglioni

Hundreds of bleached bones and skulls found in the desolate wilderness of the Sahara desert may be the remains of the long lost Cambyses' army, according to Italian researchers. Alfredo and Angelo Castiglioni

Discovery News follows up on a report first filed by Herodotus:

The remains of a mighty Persian army said to have drowned in the sands of the western Egyptian desert 2,500 years ago might have been finally located, solving one of archaeology’s biggest outstanding mysteries, according to Italian researchers. Bronze weapons, a silver bracelet, an earring and hundreds of human bones found in the vast desolate wilderness of the Sahara desert have raised hopes of finally finding the lost army of Persian King Cambyses II. The 50,000 warriors were said to be buried by a cataclysmic sandstorm in 525 B.C.

WATCH VIDEO: Take a closer look at a valley of bones that researchers think may belong to the fabled lost army of Cambyses II.

Read more…

There are, however, serious reasons to be skeptical of the filmmakers claims. The always excellent Rogueclassicism blog is on the case.

7,800 Athenians, all in the Pnyx (aka Stokes Auditorium)

Greetings Athenians,

As you milled around the Agora yesterday, you probably thought that Athens seemed a little empty. Never fear, 7,800Athenians will be in attendance at the meeting of the Ekklesia tomorrow. Here’s how.

It would unmanageable for thousands and thousands of Athenians to all participate actively in open, formal debate in the Ekklesia. Instead, as we have seen in Thucydides, the ideas of various groups, factions, and constituencies  were represented by leaders, those who could stand before the crowd and argue passionately in favor of their supporters’ interests. In our Athens, there 39 such leaders–you.

People noticed that when the Spartans left you took the initiative and headed to the Agora to discuss what Athens should do next. They were impressed and see you as a natural leader. At this point, you can be assumed to speak for 200 other Athenian citizens in the Ekklesia. But support can be fleeting. If you fail to represent your supporters, either by consistently speaking against their interests, or failing to appear in the Ekklesia, you may see your support drift away to other leaders.

Clarifying the state of the Thirty & the 3000

“As to the Thirty, they retired to Eleusis…” (Xenophon, Hellenica II)

Remember, the Thirty are not all dead. A few died in the fighting, including Critias. But most are alive, and under Spartan protection less than 15 miles away in Eleusis–roughly as far as Swarthmore is from Haverford.

The 3000, however, refer roughly to the top 3000 Athenians by wealth, excluding those who went into exile (like Thrasybulus) when the Thirty were imposed by Sparta. That is to say, they include many of you.

I recommend that you review the last section of the reading for today “The Withdrawing of the Thirty” to get a better sense of the lay of the land. For a fuller account of the Terror, you may also want to review Lysias, Against Eratosthenes (from which you have already read excerpts for our class on justice).

Feel free to use this post as the discussion thread for discussing the Reconciliation Agreement.

Embassy to the Oracle

The embassy to the Oracle has returned with the following message…

“Athenian, to your own self be true
Seek out friend, seek out foe,
find allies, find enemies.
Conceal yourself no more.”

You may now reveal yourself to other Athenians as you see fit.

Tribal Lists

Aegeïs

ebarnett@haverford.edu

Adrastos, son of Theophilos

Kolonos

20s

Pentacosiomedimnoi

cbax@haverford.edu

Demetrius, son of Epistrophos

Kollytos

30s

Zeugetai

jhunter@haverford.edu

Alkaios, son of Patrokles

Kolonos

30s

Hippies

eisaac@haverford.edu

Androcles, son of Theodotus

Kolonos

30s

Zeugetai

jlee@haverford.edu

Sophodorus, son of Phaidros

Kolonos

30s

Pentacosiomedimnoi

mliscovi@haverford.edu

Stephanos, son of Euaristos

Kolonos

30s

Thete

ctaverne@haverford.edu

Xanthipppos, son of Polycarpus

Kolonos

40s

Hippies

jmtaylor@brynmawr.edu

Hagnias, son of Dromeas

Erchia

30s

Pentakosmiomedimnoi

Aiantis

abuzzell@haverford.edu

Alexandros, son of Diokles

Marathon

Teens

Zeugetai

kdopulos@haverford.edu

Diokles, son of Anicetus

Phaleron

60s

Thete

sgant@haverford.edu

Archippos, son of Eustathios

Rhamnous

40s

Hippies

clawler@haverford.edu

Xenon, son of Bion

Rhamnous

30s

Thete

sleath@haverford.edu

Kallikrates, son of Nikandros

Marathon

20s

Pentacosiomedimnoi

cmmueller@brynmawr.edu

Nikomedes, son of Eutychides

Phaleron

30s

Zeugetai

mschiefe@haverford.edu

Pantheras, son of Nikandros

Phaleron/Athens

30s

Hippies

Akamantis

jposner@haverford.edu

Dioscorides, son of Hermolaos

Cholargos/Athens

60s

Hippies

Antiochis

sjharris@haverford.edu

Polykarpos, son of Demetrios

Atene

40s

Thete

atonsing@haverford.edu

Andokides, son of Nicias

Alopeke

30s

Pentacosiomedimnoi

swallace@haverford.edu

Nicolaus, son of Themistocles

Alopeke

30s

Pentacosiomedimnoi

Erechtheïs

hgallway@haverford.edu

Heliodorus, son of Paramonos

Anagyrous/Athens

30s

Thete

agarrity@brynmawr.edu

Thrasymachus, son of Kephisodoros

Anagyrous

30s

Pentacosiomedimnoi

spreston@haverford.edu

Adelphos, son of Cosmas

Euonymon/Athens, Piraeus

50s

Pentacosiomedimnoi

zwoerner@haverford.edu

Diotimes, son of Aeschylus

Euonymon

60s

Pentacosiomedimnoi

Hippothontis

sdisch@haverford.edu

Menexus, son of Dimas

Korydallos/Athens

20s

Pentacosiomedimnoi

cfiedler@haverford.edu

Zosimos, son of Kallistos

Korydallos

40s

Thete

zneedell@haverford.edu

Diogenes, son of Phaedrus

Korydallos/Athens

60s

Zeugetai

nolin@haverford.edu

Agathon, son of Athenandros

Piraeus

30s

Zeugetai

mromais@haverford.edu

Praxiteles, Son of Demetrios

Piraeus

30s

Hippies

ewashburn@brynmawr.edu

Euthymius, son of Argyros

Piraeus

40s

Hippies

jcwoods@brynmawr.edu

Moskos, son of Theron

Decelea

30s

Thete

Kekropis

jlhorn@haverford.edu

Pamphilos, son of Diokles

Aixone

30s

Zeugetai

akeogh@haverford.edu

Aristomachos, son of Photios

Melite/Athens

20s

Hippies

Leontis

aclark@haverford.edu

Ariston, son of Nikostratos

Halimous

20s

Zeugetai

stilson@haverford.edu

Agathon, son of Tisamenos

Ketos

40s

Pentacosiomedimnoi

Oeneïs

ffoxley@haverford.edu

Philoneos, son of Antiphon

Acharnae

30s

Zeugetai

Pandionis

nskhalid@brynmawr.edu

Thrasybulus, son of Lycus

Steiria

40s

Pentacosiomedimnoi

sodiase@haverford.edu

Kallikrates, son of Nikandros

Kydathenaion

60s

Hippies

mtsmith@haverford.edu

Michinos, son of Aniketos

Konthyle

30s

Hippies

Athens 403: Social and Economic Effects of the Peloponnesian War

In this survey of Athens in 403, we will look at the socio-economic situation after the Peloponnesian War, focusing on the loss of Empire, the economic cost in Attica, and demographic changes.

Athenian currency: 1 talent = 6,000 drachma; a drachma = the daily wage for a rower or trained craftsmen = 6 obols.

The Loss of Empire

The loss of their empire was the most significant change the confronted the Athenians in 403 BCE.

  • The Empire was extremely profitable for the Athenians.
    • In 431 BCE, tribute was over 600 talents; in 425: 1300 talents; in 413: 900 talents.
    • This revenue supported 6,000 jurors who receive 3 obols per day for 150-200 days/year (75-100 drachmas/year); as well as tens of thousands of sailors and hoplites who earned drachma or more per day when deployed.
    • An additional 5,000-10,000 Athenians were kleruchs, who had received property around Aegean in the land of the subject allies. We should not underestimate the value of these kleruchies, even for small-scale farmers. If a brother went to Amphipolis as a kleruch, the remaining family did not have to share their property, with the effect that all were better off.
    • Many of the wealthier Athenians
  • Under the Empire, all strategic goods, such as timber, wax, iron, flax, grain, were required to be shipped to or through Piraeus. Since the Athenians assessed a 2% duty on goods imported into Piraeus, the Athenians profited from much of the trade within their empire.
    • in 413 BCE, total trade in the Empire was valued at 18,000 talents (108 million drachmas); of which 1/4 travelled through Piraeus (4,500 tal); from this trade, Athens received tax revenue over 60 talents per year.
    • in 402/1: trade at Piraeus totaled 1,800 talents, a reduction of 60% over the wartime high. Tax revenue would likewise have fallen to less than 24 talents per year.

With the loss of Empire, therefore, the Athenians lost nearly all of their overseas property–a deprivation that would have effected members of all economic classes, either directly through loss of property, or through the return of family members who held kleruchies. The Athenians also lost revenues from tribute and taxations in excess of 1,000 talents per year. Of course, without the need to maintain a large fleet, operating expenses plummeted by perhaps 1,500 talents per year.

The Economic Cost of the War in Attica

Near the start of the Peloponnesian War in 428 BCE, Athenians were able to raise 200 talents from theeisphora, the property tax of 1 or 2 %. This implies that wealthy Athens had property (timema) worth between 10,000 and 20,000 talents. Based on data from the 4th century, it seems probable that the total value of property in Attica in 403 was less than 5,000 talents, indicating a loss of at least 40 and perhaps more than 75% during the war.

The losses sustained by Ischomachus, the subject of Xenophon’s Oeconomicus, are indicative of what many of the wealthy experienced: the value of his property fell from 70 to 20 talents during the war, a decline of more than 70 %. But 20 talents is still represents a sizable estate. Those who started out with less than a talent of capital, however,  their financial and property losses could have easily sent their families into the thetic class.

Agriculture: despite the raids from the Spartan garrison at Decelea, olive production likely experienced only a small decline during the War. Animal husbandry, however, would have suffered significantly. The 8 months of civil war in 403, however, could have caused noticeable disruptions in agricultural production. We should assume that by 403, Athens was importing more of its basic foodstuffs than at any point in memory.

Slaves: Part of the economic loss resulted from the more than 20,000 slaves who escaped their Athenian masters (most to the Spartan garrison at Decelea). At a value of 150-200 drachmas per slave, the flight of slaves represented a loss of more than 500 talents, not even including the lost economic output if the slaves were not replaced.

Commerce: the loss of preferential trading rights within the empire certainly damaged Athenian commercial concerns, as did the collapse of silver mining. The necessity to import so many basic foodstuffs, however, likely mitigated the short-term damage to the export business. Certain business, such as fishing, could immediately return to full production, although the sale of luxury foods and goods would suffer because of the general decline of demand.

Light Industry: these small-scale factories, which averaged 20-30 people (none were larger than 120) crafted pots, knives, lamps, clothing, leather goods, weapons, ships, jewelry, etc. Light industry suffered less than mining and farming during the War; but escaping slaves and general draining of resources from 413-403 led to lower domestic demand. Military materiel was, of course, the exception to this rule until the end of hostilities.

Mining: after the investment of the Spartan garrison at Decelea, silver mining in Laurion was dramatically reduced. The extent of the economic loss is unknown, but was certainly substantial.

Demographic Change

As described in the post on population trends during the Peloponnesian War, the war altered the composition of the demos. The losses, however, were born disproportionately by the different classes of society during the different phases of the war. During the Archidamian War (431-421), the majority of the military causalities were suffered by hoplites; in the war’s second phase, the Ionian-Declean War (416-404), the loses by  the thetes, who manned the vital triremes, continued to mount at an alarming pace until the war ended.

war casualties

As a result of the escalating thetic casualties, the demos was more or less evenly divided between thetes and the top three Solonic classes by 403 BCE.

Previous Entries in this Series:

Greek Sculpture

This 2-minute excerpt from the BBC series “How Art Made the World” that demonstrates how Polykleitos posed his famous Doryphoros statue to capture the range of the human form in four quadrants of a single statue.

Get the Flash Player to see the wordTube Media Player.

This longer 10-minute excerpt from the same series describes the revolutionary development of Classical sculpture in the fifth century.

Get the Flash Player to see the wordTube Media Player.

Video: Peloponnesian War to Year 413

This short video maps the major activities of each year of the Peloponnesian War (up to 413 BCE).

Click here for a full-sized version.

Get the Flash Player to see the wordTube Media Player.

Study Guide for Midterm

Here’s the Study Guide for the Midterm.

Study sessions will be held Wednesday and Thursday, 7:30-9:30

The exam will be closed book, take home, and due at the start of class on Monday, November 9th (you may submit it earlier, of course).

As you now doubt know, you have learned a lot about Athenian (and other Greek) culture in the seventh, sixth, and especially fifth centuries.

The lists in the Study Guide include most characters, events, and ideas that we have encountered. If you can say something about all of them, you will be in excellent shape–although not every item is of equal importance. Obviously you should be able to say more about Pericles or the Persian Wars than “the messenger” in the Bacchae (although we did discuss why messengers generally are important in tragedy).

Finally, since some of the information will be drawn from the last half of the Peloponnesian War, a few items on the list may look unfamiliar at this point. We will get to these people and events soon.

My office hours are Monday 2:30-4 and Tuesday 10-2; Professor Germany has hours Thursday morning. As I mentioned yesterday, we will have a review session or two next week.

Staypressed theme by Themocracy